As the geek community becomes more and more mainstream, some of the dark elements within our niche are floating to the top, like scum on a pond. And it is up to us to deal with it, not merely shrug our shoulders and pass the buck. To catch up those who missed it, Jessica Nigri went on Twitch to play video games. And so, out came the trolls.
And as usual, it is intrinsically linked to misogyny.
It is incredibly saddening but this kind of thing has become so commonplace that it no longer surprising and barely offends anymore. These attacks on women in the geek world happen daily and are all-pervasive. When FoodAndCosplay created the #NotACosplayer campaign, it was inundated with replies about how certain things weren’t cosplay, how some people were ruining cosplay and the like.
And the hashtag revealed even more:
We took the time to speak to a few cosplayers about their experiences and some incredibly saddening stories emerged:
I had a good friend recommend I bring back my Misty cosplay (I cosplayed her a while back) so I did… As soon as I posted it on a Cosplay group on Facebook I got bombarded with comments such as “Misty’s boobs are not that big” “The way you’re posing look stupid” “ Your boobs look weird” “That’s not cute at all." Truth be told it broke my heart and I took the post down. –- SuperSonicSky
The first was my first con cosplaying earlier this year. I was with Maria (my cosplay partner) and we were dressed as Harley Quinn and Poison Ivy. So, when a group of 5 guys came up to us I didn’t really think much of it. They all asked and were really polite, first few guys had their pictures taken and then the last guy walked over. He was also in cosplay but I couldn’t place who he was. He had big shoulder pads on with red and white stripes on one side and blue and silver stars on the other. In my haze of the day and the excitement of it all I said, “Oh hey you’re Captain America –- awesome.” He laughed in my face, turned round to his friends, pointed his thumb at me and said “She thinks I’m Captain America.” He posed for his picture and walked off with his friends still chuckling. He just mocked me & walked off. I felt awful, it takes a lot to rock my confidence but that really did it. I felt like a sham. One of those “fake geek girls” who don’t know enough about comics etc. Later I was able to place the character, he was The Comedian from Watchmen. A comic that I had only recently (pre-con) devoured in the space of a few days and loved. Didn’t stop me from feeling like a complete chump at the time and I still look back now and cringe at my awful ignorance. I was so angry after. I just kept thinking “If that had been a 14 girl old girl, who had saved up her pocket money to make her outfit she would have been devastated.” –- KiaCosplay
People need to realise behind the picture is a person who put time, effort and money into this cosplay. Even though my cosplay was accurate, my body shape made me into a “Slut,” sexualising cosplay when this is not the case. I can see why most people are intimidated to join the con community and start cosplaying. -– SuperSonicSky
If you’ll allow me to be frank for a moment, what the bloody hell is wrong with people?
Look, I get it. I’m now 31 and I’ve been a geek almost all my life. I’ve been going to conventions since I was 14 and they were 30 heavy-set men crowding round a desk full of floppy disks. As a teenager, the geek culture was a place of safety for me, a place to feel at home. I was never sporty, never a cool kid with all the toys. All I had was smarts and a love of sci-fi. And that worked in the fandoms, it didn’t matter what I looked like, it didn’t matter what I did, all that mattered was what I knew. That was comforting, that the arbitrary rules that held sway over the rest of the world did not apply here.
And then it all changed. Nerd Culture became mainstream culture. The public face of the scene was changing. There was a massive influx of people and money into this once dark corner of my world. And with this influx, came many many changes. One of the biggest was that of demographic. Whilst the men I grew up with were there, there were also many new faces. Faces of colour, female faces, young faces. And as these people joined us, it allowed their peers, who had long hung in the background of geekdom, to rise with them. In time, the culture changed to include their views.
And change can be scary. Suddenly those rules that we held sway against started to affect our world, started to have weight. What you looked like mattered, you were judged on it. How cool you were matter, how much you knew mattered less.
But you know what, we are the ones doing the judging. Not them.
We are the ones getting protective, we are the ones enforcing some idiotic idea of how things should be enjoyed or consumed. You don’t see the folks who came to Marvel via the MCU judge those who read for 20 years, you don’t see folks at their first con sneer at those vets who have been around for years.
It is us, the old guard, drawing imaginary lines in the sand and saying those over there, they aren’t real fans.
And I for one will not stand for it.
The basic idea of the geek community is come as you are.
We were the ones who would take those who could go nowhere else. When did that change? You don’t get to decide how someone else interacts with the thing you love.
IT IS NOT YOURS.
Even if you made it, once it hits the wider world, IT IS NOT YOURS. You don’t get to decide that Jessica Nigri isn’t worthy of her renown because of any reason. Don’t like her? Don’t watch her. Do your own thing. Your time in the community does not give you more right. Your skin colour does not give you more right. Your dick does not give you more right.
This is my community, these are the people I love and the places I am whole. My truest friends have been forged in our love of Picard, of Reynolds, of Briene. I will fight for it to remain a place of safety, of openness and welcome. We will take in all. Those who just fancy Chris Evans and those who have read Cap since Issue 1, those who waited seven years for Dance With Dragons and those who have never seen it but love the Daenerys cosplay they see around.
There are no gatekeepers to this community, no test to pass or requirements to fulfill. Come as you are, let me show you what I love, show me what you love. This is my home and there will always be a place for you.
And so to the trolls I say this: Grow up or get the F off my lawn.
Reprinted with permission from Need to Consume